In the waning days of the war, the US Navy had dispatched a squadron of ships to the Indian Ocean to disrupt the valuable British commerce in that part of the globe. The frigate President, under Stephen Decatur, was to be the squadron’s flagship, but she unfortunately fell into the hands of a British squadron soon after leaving New York. Unaware of the President’s capture, the remaining American ships, consisting of the sloops Peacock and Hornet, and the supply ship Tom Bowline, slipped through the British blockade and made it to sea.
After a series of rousing adventures, the three vessels became separated. The Peacock alone continued the mission and sailed on into the eastern Indian Ocean. The 22-gun sloop-of-war was commanded by 33 year old Master Commandant Lewis Warrington. He was impetuous, courageous, dashing, and the illegitimate son of a French nobleman who fought for the American cause during the Revolution. Warrington made a name for himself the year before by capturing the British man-of-war brig Epervier, and fourteen other prizes. Not content to rest on his laurels, Warrington knew he could score some rich prizes in the waters between India and Indonesia.
|Master Commandant Lewis Warrington, engraved for the Analectic Magazine in 1815. USS Constitution Museum collection.|
On the last day of June, 1815, Peacock came abreast of the coast of Anjier (modern Anyer), Java, in the Sunda Straits, and hoisted British colors. In the distance, and closing rapidly, was a brig flying the flag of the British East India Company. This brig, called the Nautilus, was on a passage from Java to Bengal, and having just received official confirmation that hostilities had ceased between the United States and Great Britain had no reason to suspect that a strange vessel flying British colors presented a threat. Nautilus’ captain Lt. Charles Boyce sent his master on board with the news, but as he watched the boat come alongside the strange vessel, he saw the crew immediately called onto deck and the boat taken in tow. At the same time, a boat from the shore had joined the stranger, and her crew met with the same treatment.
Sensing danger, Boyce prepared his ship for action. On the Peacock, Warrington seemed unsure of how to proceed. He had prepared his ship for battle, too, but the news of peace between the two nations caused him to waiver. The British taken prisoner from the boats claimed to have proof of the peace treaty, in no less a form than President Madison’s own proclamation. Still, Warrington was determined to “have a little brush” with the British, and his subsequent actions were calculated to cause a fight. As the two ships neared each other, Warrington hailed the Nautilus, and ordered her to haul down her colors immediately. Boyce refused, and immediately the Peacock opened fire on her much smaller opponent.
Both sides fired in quick succession, but the Nautilus received the worst of it. Peacock’s first broadside killed two men and severely wounded Lt. Boyce (a grape shot round passed through his body above his hip). The next broadside killed and wounded more men. A 32 lb ball smashed Boyce’s right knee cap and gravely wounded his second in command. With all of the British officers incapacitated, the Nautilus surrendered.
Warrington evidently immediately regretted his decision to open fire, but continued to act petulantly toward the British he had so thoroughly vanquished. He gave the Nautilus back the next day, but continued to insist that he had been in the right. An American court of inquiry later agreed, and cleared him of all wrongdoing.
Warrington went on to a long career in the US Navy, and eventually died in 1851 after fifty years of service. Poor Charles Boyce had his leg amputated above the knee, and had to retire from the East India Company’s service in 1817. Nevertheless, he was awarded a pension by the East India Company and lived to collect it until 1878!